The 2025 NCAA Division I Wrestling Championships in Philadelphia witnessed a monumental achievement by the Penn State Nittany Lions, as they became only the second team in NCAA history to produce 10 All-Americans in a single season. This remarkable feat, previously accomplished only by the 2001 Minnesota squad, underscores the program’s unparalleled dominance in collegiate wrestling.
Under the expert guidance of head coach Cael Sanderson, Penn State not only secured 10 All-American honors but also clinched their 13th national team title, with a record-breaking 177 points—surpassing their own previous record of 172.5 points set in 2024. The Nittany Lions’ performance was nothing short of extraordinary, with all 10 wrestlers finishing in the top eight of their respective weight classes, ensuring their All-American status.
Among the standout performances, Carter Starocci made history by becoming the first-ever five-time NCAA champion, achieving this feat in the 184-pound weight class after previously winning four titles at 174 pounds. Additionally, Mitchell Mesenbrink secured the national title at 165 pounds, contributing significantly to the team’s success.
The All-American honorees for Penn State included Luke Lilledahl (125 lbs), Braeden Davis (133 lbs), Beau Bartlett (141 lbs), Shayne Van Ness (149 lbs), Levi Haines (157 lbs), Mitchell Mesenbrink (165 lbs), Carter Starocci (174 lbs), Josh Barr (184 lbs), Greg Kerkvliet (197 lbs), and Tyler Kasak (285 lbs). Their collective achievements not only highlight individual excellence but also reflect the depth and strength of the Penn State wrestling program.
This historic season solidifies Penn State’s position as a powerhouse in collegiate wrestling and sets a new benchmark for future teams to aspire to. The Nittany Lions’ unparalleled success this year is a testament to their dedication, skill, and the visionary leadership of Coach Sanderson.
