Carter Starocci has etched his name into NCAA wrestling history by becoming the first Division I wrestler to secure five national championships. This unprecedented achievement was realized at the 2025 NCAA Division I Wrestling Championships held at the Wells Fargo Center in Philadelphia. Starocci triumphed in the 184-pound weight class, defeating Parker Keckeisen of Northern Iowa in the final .
Starocci’s journey to this historic milestone began in 2020, when he clinched his first national title at 174 pounds. He continued his dominance over the next four years, culminating in his fifth title in 2025. Notably, the NCAA granted an eligibility waiver to athletes during the 2020–21 season due to the COVID-19 pandemic, allowing Starocci to extend his collegiate career and pursue this record-breaking feat .
Throughout his career, Starocci compiled an impressive 104–4 record and was named the Most Outstanding Wrestler of the 2025 Championships. His consistency and resilience were evident as he navigated through various challenges, including injuries and tough competition, to maintain his status as a top contender in collegiate wrestling .
Beyond his individual success, Starocci’s legacy is intertwined with the rise of Penn State wrestling under coach Cael Sanderson. His five titles contribute to the program’s 13th national team championship and its record-breaking performance in the 2025 tournament, where the Nittany Lions set a new team points record with 177 points.
Looking ahead, Starocci is exploring opportunities in mixed martial arts. He has been seen training at American Top Team in Florida, alongside notable figures such as Bellator champion Johnny Eblen and fellow Penn State alumnus Bo Nickal . His transition from collegiate wrestling to professional MMA is highly anticipated by fans and analysts alike.
Carter Starocci’s unprecedented five national titles have solidified his place as one of the greatest wrestlers in NCAA history. His dedication, skill, and sportsmanship continue to inspire future generations of athletes.
