Paul Finebaum didn’t hold back when asked about Tennessee’s current quarterback situation, delivering a scathing assessment that’s lighting a fire under the Vols fan base. The longtime college football analyst, known for his sharp takes and SEC insight, called out Tennessee’s quarterback room as “one of the biggest liabilities in the conference” and said the Volunteers “have no business dreaming of the playoffs” unless something drastically changes.
In a recent segment on ESPN, Finebaum zeroed in on what he perceives as inconsistency, lack of leadership, and underwhelming production under center. “Let’s stop pretending like Tennessee is knocking on the door of the CFP,” he said. “They don’t even know who their guy is at quarterback. That kind of uncertainty doesn’t beat Alabama or Georgia. That kind of uncertainty doesn’t belong in the playoff conversation.”
It’s a tough pill to swallow for a program that’s been trying to claw its way back into national relevance. Under Josh Heupel, the Vols have shown flashes of brilliance, particularly in 2022 with Hendon Hooker at the helm. But with Hooker gone to the NFL and the next man up struggling to meet expectations, Finebaum argues the team has regressed at the most critical position.
Vols fans may not like the harsh words, but they serve as a wake-up call. This isn’t about hate — it’s about reality. Championship teams are built around confident, productive quarterbacks, and right now, Tennessee’s situation doesn’t inspire fear in opponents or confidence in fans.
Still, criticism like this can serve a purpose. If anything, it’s a motivator. The Vols have talent. They have a passionate fan base. And they have a coach known for high-powered offenses. What they need now is a leader under center who can silence the doubters and prove that Tennessee belongs in the elite tier of college football.
So to the quarterbacks in Knoxville — this is your challenge. Finebaum has thrown down the gauntlet. Now it’s up to you to pick it up and prove him wrong.
